
For this write-up, I found and read the sources myself, and outlined the piece; the draft was written by Claude Opus 5.5, and I revised it extensively.
Universities are where knowledge is made, verified and passed on by senior academics and their teams. They do this through two jobs: teaching the next generation, and deciding through peer review and publication which findings count. Now anyone can get a professor-level tutor at two in the morning, for free, and AI can draft a passable research paper overnight. So what is a university for? I am a nutritional epidemiologist, and fields like mine move at a glacial pace: paper by paper, presentation by presentation, conference by conference. AI is arriving like a freight train, and it will push aside anyone who does not hop on.
We seek knowledge to understand how the world works and to improve lives, our own, and those of others. Universities serve both ends and pass them on. They have relied on two kinds of evidence, and AI has weakened both: a student’s written work as proof of learning, and a scientist’s paper as proof of a finding. What remains for universities is the slow work of testing hypotheses against the world and training the people who do it.
The teacher and the test
For most of history, learning meant finding a learned person. Students in Baghdad, Damascus and Córdoba travelled for years to read a text with a named teacher, who then wrote a licence vouching for both the student and the copy they wrote. When cheap paper reached Baghdad in the eighth century and books multiplied, trust still rested on who had taught you. Universities and journals later formalized a similar double promise: the degree vouches for the student, and peer review vouches for the work. AI strains both, starting with the degree.
An AI tutor can teach, if it is built to. In a randomized trial in Harvard’s largest physics class, a carefully designed tutor more than doubled learning gains over an active-learning class, on tests taken the same day. A careless one does harm. In a trial with high-school mathematics students, a standard chatbot raised practice scores by 48%, yet the students later scored 17% lower than controls on an exam taken without it. Their work improved while their learning fell.
That is the problem for the degree, because for centuries universities have judged learning by what students write. Kevin Bryan, an economist at the University of Toronto, puts it plainly: “the link between performance and student knowledge has been broken.” He now asks students for an early précis, shows them what a frontier model can already produce from it, and requires their final paper to be better. I expect the degree to move toward certifying what a graduate can do without the machine. Baghdad did something similar in 931: after a fatal medical error, it barred its physicians until each passed an examination and received a certificate naming exactly what he could practise. The degree of the future will look more like that certificate than a transcript: a promise that a human has verified the ability.
The gate moves
Publishing, the second job, is strained harder. The tools that make papers cheap also make slop cheap. Submissions to arXiv, the main preprint server for physics and AI, doubled in two years to 40,363 in September alone; on 1 October it limited each submitter to two a month. Single-factor papers mined from one US health and nutrition survey rose from about four a year to 190 in 2024, counted only to 9 October. People still have to judge what is true and what matters but with such immense load, how can they cope anymore! As usual, gatekeepers will resist any change to the status quo, but I doubt they will decide the outcome. The frontier of AI research already sits outside the universities, inside companies where AI writes most of the code and much of that work can happen out of public view. A generation that can do research with AI will not wait for their permission.
That is why I expect journals, as they stand, to disappear, and better venues to replace them. Writing a paper is becoming routine work for machines, and papers are already being turned into agents that answer questions about the work and rerun its methods. The record will split in two: a few pages for people to read, and hundreds of pages of data, code and logs for agents, because a single narrative can no longer serve both readers. A peer-reviewed test shows why the logs matter: an AI auditor checking the output of AI “scientist” systems did barely better than chance from the manuscript alone (54% accuracy) but reached 82% with the logs and code. The new venues are already being built. aiXiv is a preprint archive for research by human and AI scientists, with AI-assisted review; AgentRxiv, a research prototype, lets AI agents post their findings and build on one another’s work. Prestige will move from a journal’s name to whether the results hold.
Agents will write and check, but a named person will still have to sign off. As machines perfect the technical links, Naveed Aziz argues, human judgment becomes the link on which everything depends. The physicist Matthew Schwartz found the same when he let Claude loose on problems outside his field: its results were almost always technically correct, yet not all that interesting until an expert in that field steered the work (Schwartz, 2026). That step, from a hypothesis to true knowledge, still needs scientists with a real grasp of the topic. It is also the slowest link. As papers multiply, those scientists will need agents of their own to check results and judge which ones matter. Research is becoming a joint human–agent effort at every stage: refining ideas, running analyses, writing the paper and reviewing it.
Hypotheses and knowledge
Machines can already take the first half of that step. They produce hypotheses faster than we can test them: in one survey of 637 scientists, 41% said their backlog of untested hypotheses had grown, which the report links to AI. Most hypotheses begin as imaginative guesswork, as the immunologist Peter Medawar argued. A hypothesis becomes knowledge only by passing the test we set for it. A thousand years ago, Ibn al-Haytham wrote that the seeker after truth is not the one who trusts the writings of the ancients, “but rather the one who suspects his faith in them and questions what he gathers from them.” We, as scientists, should treat AI’s answers the same way.
In September, a group including Geoffrey Hinton and Yoshua Bengio warned that AI may soon automate AI research itself, compressing years of progress into months or less. They also conceded that fields such as biology may have to rely more on slower, costlier feedback from the real world. The futurist Ramez Naam, skeptical of such forecasts, draws the line more sharply: AI will become superhuman mainly where a machine can verify the answer, as in formal mathematics. On 6 October, OpenAI released 372 results, many checked by proof software, though mathematicians may need months to understand them. Christian Szegedy likens such systems to the Wright brothers’ first plane: crude, yet already landing on rocks no climber had reached.
Nutritional epidemiology sits firmly on the slow side. A model can suggest that a sweetener might change appetite. Knowing whether it does takes an interventional trial or an observational study in real people. Ibn Sina made the same demand of medicines a millennium ago: test them on the human body, because a drug might act differently in “the lion’s body or the horse’s body.” AI will multiply the hypotheses in nutritional science and similarly in clinical sciences; but trials in people will still set the pace.
What survives
Those trials need people who can run and judge them. AI can help train those people, as a well-built tutor does, but it also means fewer of them are needed. At US firms that adopted generative AI, junior employment fell about 9% relative to senior staff within six quarters. Even Schwartz admits he still does not know how to train graduate students. Universities must keep some junior work for the young on purpose, or no one will be left who can check the machines.
So I expect the university to shrink toward what cannot be digitized: laboratories, clinics, cohorts, and mentors who model judgment. A machine can produce answers, but it does not ask what needs be tested in real world. Curiosity and the desire to improve lives are ours, and apprenticeship under human mentors is how the young will learn this craft. The old scholars trusted a text because of who taught it. We will trust a result because of who tested it, and universities must keep training those people.
Tauseef Khan is a Senior Research Associate in the Department of Nutritional Sciences at the University of Toronto. He studies dietary sugars, honey, sweeteners and chronic disease, and has recently been building AI workflows for systematic reviews and writing about how AI is changing science. The views here are his own.
Sources
Aziz N. The scaffolding of wisdom and the human architecture of judgment: discernment in the age of AI. LinkedIn, 25 Jan 2026.
Bastani H, Bastani O, Sungu A, et al. Generative AI without guardrails can harm learning: evidence from high school mathematics. PNAS 2025;122:e2422633122.
Bloom JM. Paper Before Print: The History and Impact of Paper in the Islamic World. Yale University Press, 2001.
Boboris K. Fair moderation, equitable access, and AI: arXiv’s updated rate limit policy. arXiv blog, 1 Oct 2026.
Bryan KA. Eight rules for teaching in AI world. kevinbryanecon.com, Aug 2026.
Chan A, Winter C, Barto A, et al. What if automating AI R&D triggers an intelligence explosion? CASP Frontier AI Working Paper 2/2026.
Codreanu M, Imas A, Mateos-Garcia J, et al. AI in Science: Early Insights. Google, 2026.
Hosseini SM, Lichtinger G. Generative AI as seniority-biased technological change. SSRN working paper, 2025. doi:10.2139/ssrn.5425555.
Howlett J. OpenAI unleashes hundreds more math results upon a field already in shock. Scientific American, 6 Oct 2026.
Ibn Abi Usaybiʿa. ʿUyun al-anbaʾ fi tabaqat al-atibbaʾ (13th c.), quoting Thabit ibn Sinan on the 931 examination. English trans. L. Kopf.
Kestin G, Miller K, Klales A, et al. AI tutoring outperforms in-class active learning: an RCT introducing a novel research-based design in an authentic educational setting. Sci Rep 2025;15:17458.
Liu J, Pei J, Huang J, et al. The last human-written paper: agent-native research artifacts. arXiv:2604.24658, 2026.
Luo Z, Kasirzadeh A, Shah NB. The more you automate, the less you see: hidden pitfalls of autonomous AI scientists. PNAS 2026;123(41):e2610214123.
Miao J, Davis JR, Zhang Y, Pritchard JK, Zou J. Reimagining research papers as interactive and reliable AI agents. Nature 2026. doi:10.1038/s41586-026-11044-y.
Naam R. Where’s the “intelligence explosion”? Noahpinion, 27 Sep 2026.
Nasser M, Tibi A, Savage-Smith E. Ibn Sina’s Canon of Medicine: 11th century rules for assessing the effects of drugs. J R Soc Med 2009;102:78–80.
Sabra AI. Ibn al-Haytham. Harvard Magazine, Sep–Oct 2003 (on the Aporias against Ptolemy).
Schmidgall S, Moor M. AgentRxiv: towards collaborative autonomous research. arXiv:2503.18102, 2025.
Schwartz MD. Claude-shaped science. Anthropic research blog (guest post), 1 Oct 2026. The author was a visiting researcher at Anthropic during the project.
Stewart DJ. Ejāza. Encyclopaedia Iranica VIII/3, 1998.
Suchak T, et al. Explosion of formulaic research articles, including inappropriate study designs and false discoveries, based on the NHANES US national health database. PLoS Biol 2025;23:e3003152.
Szegedy C. Quo vadis, mathematics? Is mathematics over, or just graduating? Essay, 3 Oct 2026.
Tregoning JS. Is the scientific paper still a fraud? PLoS Biol 2026;24(8):e3003912 (on Medawar, “Is the scientific paper a fraud?”, The Listener, 1963).
Zhang P, Hu X, Huang G, et al. aiXiv: a next-generation open access ecosystem for scientific discovery generated by AI scientists. arXiv:2508.15126, 2025 (platform: aixiv.science).
